A Year in Review: Concerns in 2009

  • Closing Canada’s Doors to Refugees

    NuemiandBebeCreditDavidCooperGetStockcom.jpg

    In the summer of 2009, the Canadian government dramatically closed the door on people seeking Canada’s protection, by imposing visa requirements on the Czech Republic and Mexico (despite the serious human rights abuses occurring in those countries), and by turning back nationals of moratoria countries (Afghanistan, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Haiti, Iraq and Zimbabwe) who make claims at the US-Canada border. Many of these people would have been recognized as refugees in Canada, but now risk being deported by the US.

  • Erosion of Government Commitment to Refugee Rights

    Vicente and his family, profiled by CCR in 2009.

    Refugees have also been hurt by the highly negative language used to discuss them publicly. References by representatives of the federal government to “bogus” claimants and similar misleading and disparaging terms have been widely repeated in the media. Government discourse has fostered hostility towards refugees, making them feel less welcome in Canada and undermining public support for refugee protection. The negative rhetoric has also fed into more general xenophobia and racism, affecting not only refugees, but also immigrants and racialized minorities.

  • Overseas Processing Delays: Protection delayed, protection denied

    Jordan and Lisa with their mother.  Processing at Nairobi took 5 years.

    Long delays are a well-known feature of Canadian immigration processing, but the Nairobi visa office stands out for its extraordinarily long processing times. In 2009 processing times got slower at Nairobi. In 2008, half of privately sponsored refugees waited more than 40 months. As of mid-2009 the visa processing time was up to 42 months (3½ years). Nairobi is by far the slowest visa office for privately sponsored refugees.

    Family members of refugees in Canada also face excruciatingly long waits if their case is being processed in Nairobi.

  • Children’s Rights in Focus

    Akin and his mother.  They were detained for 49 days.

    2009 marked the 20th anniversary of the signing of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. Non-citizen children, along with aboriginal children, continue to suffer the most serious breaches of Canada’s obligations towards children’s rights.

  • Temporary workers: Canada’s dramatic shift in policy

    Guatemalan worker in Quebec.  Credit: canadabrian/GetStock.com

    Canada has been bringing in more and more workers on temporary work permits, rather than as permanent residents. In recent years, the number of people in Canada as temporary foreign workers more than doubled.

    Traditionally Canada has welcomed immigrants on a permanent basis, with most becoming citizens. The recent shift to temporary migration marks a dramatic change in policy, yet there has been little public debate.

  • Two-tier citizenship called into question

    Suaad Hagi Mohamud reunited with son.  Credit: Lucas Oleniuk/GetStock.com

    2009 saw increasing concerns that not all Canadian citizens are considered equal. Changes to the Citizenship Act took effect in April 2009, with significant impacts on who can inherit Canadian citizenship from their parent. The changes effectively create two classes of citizenship, with a lower class that has no right to pass on their Canadian citizenship to their children (natural born or adopted). As a result, there is a new risk that children of Canadian citizens will be stateless.

  • Parliament and courts fail refugees

    Supreme Court of Canada

    The year began and ended with significant blows to refugees, delivered by Canada’s institutions.  In February, the Supreme Court of Canada refused to hear an appeal of the safe third country legal challenge, leaving in place the lower court ruling that allowed the government to send refugees back to the US whether or not that country is safe. The Federal Court of Appeal had ruled that the fact “that the US does not ‘actually’ comply [with its obligations to refugees] is irrelevant.

  • Government to reduce refugee and family numbers

    2010 immigration levels

    The government’s 2010 immigration plan maintains the same total number of immigrants, but reduces the numbers of refugees and Family Class immigrants. The government plans that, of new permanent residents in 2010, only 8% will be refugees. This is the lowest proportion given to refugees in at least 20 years (down from an average of 12% in the past two decades).

    For more information

    CIC, Annual Report to Parliament on Immigration, 2009

  • Transportation Loans: Heavy burdens in tough economic times

    loansstudent.gif

    There were increasing calls in 2009 for the Canadian government to absorb the costs of transportation loans for refugees and refugee families. Media across the country have depicted the dramatic impacts of the transportation debt on resettled refugees and their families. Various actors, including educators, healthcare professionals and municipal governments, have taken up the issue and are calling on the government to change its policy.

    For more information

    End the burden of transportation loans!

  • 40th Anniversary of Canada signing the Refugee Convention

    40thannivRefConvEN.jpg

    2009 marked the 40th anniversary of Canada’s signing of the Convention relating to the Status of Refugees, 18 years after it was adopted by the United Nations. CCR members used the opportunity to highlight Canada’s actions towards refugees using the theme 'Recognizing Successes, Acting for Change'.

    For more information

    40th anniversary of Canada signing the Refugee Convention, 1969-2009